Toronto is Making it Easy to Do Good!

Posted by Stephanie Miller on December 8th, 2008

Just last week the Toronto City Council announced two big policies that will help all Torontonians Do Good for the environment. The first one, effective immediately, is to ban the sale and distribution of bottled water at City Hall and civic centres across the G.T.A. By 2011, this ban will transfer to other city-owned facilities.

The second environmentally-sound motion councillors voted on was a $0.05 fee on plastic bags. Starting June 1, 2009, retailers will be required to accept reusable bags and containers in lue of retailer-supplied bags. The final tally was 30 in favour of the bag and bottle measures, 13 against.

Here is the Mayor’s reasoning from TheStar.com:

Mayor David Miller said “free” shopping bags come at a cost. “There’s a cost to the city and the people of Toronto in disposing of them, there’s a cost to the environment and there’s a cost to the retailers,” he said after the vote…

Miller defended the move [on the bottled water ban], arguing that the city produces its own high-quality water. “I don’t believe as Canada’s largest purveyor of tap water we should be selling water in our facilities,” he said.

Critics, however, suggest laws to enforce such measures are unnecessary and will hurt the economy:

Some councillors argued the new rules go too far. Councillor Karen Stintz argued for a voluntary bag fee, saying a compulsory one is unnecessary because the city will accept plastic bags in its recycling program starting next week. But Councillor Howard Moscoe said voluntary fees would be useless.

Councillor David Shiner said banning water in city-owned theatres like the Sony Centre will hurt their revenue, and workers will likely have to give away tap water in plastic cups.

Torontonians: What do you think about these decisions by the City of Toronto?

Do Gooders from around the world: Does your city have these types of laws? What do you think about it?

  • Satish

    Wait until they start telling us tax on gas is for the same reason.

  • Suzy Cruz

    I’m not quite sure that I understand if they city is banning the sales of water bottles to reduce waste in general,
    or to specifically reduce plastic waste? The article seems to be focused on plastic, so…
    Could they not sell glass bottled water instead??
    Gives people the option to buy and could help the economic factor…
    I know that glass bottles are healthier to drink from, but I’m not sure if/what kind of threats they could pose to the environment…
    Just a thought:-)

  • Steph

    @Satish: Don’t taxes, like Dion’s proposed carbon tax, be a brilliant way to discourage over-consumption in nonrenewable sources, like gas? I’d love to hear everyone’s views on this!!

    @Suzy: I think the ban includes glass because in a Metro article, “Ban not being adhered to” they talk about a cafe in City Hall still offering water in plastic bottles, as well as San Pellegrino and Perrier in glass bottles, which the owner was asked to get rid of. So I guess it’s waste in general.

    But seriously, aren’t metals toxic and aren’t the city water mains made out of lead piping? Maybe a couple of glasses of city water a week might not hurt you, but after awhile, won’t it accumulate in the body so that the liver becomes taxed and unable to process it all?

    I’m with you, Suzy, I like the idea of offering at least glass bottled water.

  • Lili

    In an apartment or condo building, one is required to securely tie up kitchen waste and garbage in a plastic bag before letting it drop down the building’s garbage chute. If they prohibit the use of plastic grocery bags, (which most people use for this purpose, what then are people expected to do? Will they have have no alternative but to buy plastic bags instead?

  • Stephanie Miller

    Hi Lili, I hear your pain. I’m in the same boat. So far this policy hasn’t affected me because I have a MILLION bags saved up - which I look forward to recycling as soon as I can find a creative alternative to my current garbage situation.

    Anyone have any ingenious ideas?

  • Jamey Norsingle

    Is there a way to stop spam? My site has been getting hammered lately with spam and I’m not sure a way to stop it.

Leave a Reply